My previous post, stating in no uncertain terms that Nazis are bad and we should disavow them, went viral.
Here are, distilled down for your ease, a list of things that people — predominantly, I can safely assume, white people — have said about that.
– Barack Obama was a racist
– Hillary Clinton was a racist
– Hillary Clinton was just as bad
– Black people are racist
– You’re the real racist, I’m not a racist
– There’s always truth on both sides of the story
– You have to listen to all people to solve problems
– If you ignore a problem it will just go away
– The Irish had it worse than the slaves
– I don’t know why you’re bringing up sexism
– Black people voted for Trump too
– Black people set things on fire too
– Black people riot in the streets all the time
– Michael Brown lunged for a cop’s gun
– It’s not like really about Jewish people
– You’re a liberal who hates freedom of speech
– You’re race-baiting
– You should die already
– I’m not like those other “bad” white people
I put the last one in bold because it’s the one I want to briefly talk about.
Hey. Friends. Addressing this part directly to other white folks. Hey, there. Hello.
When I say that “Nazis are bad,” I’m not actually calling YOU a Nazi. Unless you personally have worn a swastika, marched through the streets with torches, or run a vehicle over a group of counter-protestors, you’re fine. Sit down.
What I am saying is that white people need to wake up to what’s happening in this country. And the first way we can determine the root cause of this is to check your reflexes.
Remember that test that the doctors did at your physical? They’d hit your knee with the little hammer? Let’s give it a shot.
Fellow white people: I think Nazis are bad. Respond!
If you said anything other than, “Yes, I also think Nazis are bad” and you didn’t end the sentence with the word “BUT…” … you can skip ahead a few sentences.
If you DID feel the need to equivocate that statement — ask yourself why.
If you reflexively felt the need to add “But I’m not one of them! ” or “But all Trump voters aren’t Nazis” or “But there’s not very many real white supremacists out there” or “But Hillary was bad too” or “But if we ignore them they’ll go away” or any of the other “BUT”s out there…. stop. Take a deep breath. Look in the mirror and repeat after me.
“I think Nazis are bad” is the easiest thing in the world to say.
It’s a very low bar to hurdle. It’s why a lot of people are angry at the President of the United States for not being able to clear even that.
Without equivocating, simply say “I think Nazis are bad.” That’s it. We all know that not all white people are Nazis. If you have to say it, ask yourself why it’s so important that you be separated from them. (If you’ve ever called upon, say, Muslims to “disavow terrorism,” maybe you understand now that it doesn’t feel good to be lumped into a category of people based on the color of your skin and the volume of bad apples).
Now. Moving to the next step. Everything sure seems like it’s on fire right now, huh? And I’m a good white person who doesn’t like Nazis. What do we do now?
You say something about it. Your social media page is a good place to start.
You feel all that angst and agita about not wanting to be perceived as a “slacktivist?” That if you “do this wrong,” other people will be angry with you? That whatever you say, it won’t be enough, it won’t make a difference, no one cares what’s said on social media anyway, that your space is mostly just puppies and pictures of your kids and people might unfriend you?
You literally just have to say “Nazis are bad.” That’s it. That’s all you have to say. Or “Black Lives Matter,” or “Racism is evil and shouldn’t be tolerated,” or any number of statements that are distilled down to their essence.
You don’t have to get into why you feel the way you feel, unless you think it will help others, specifically others in your circles who could benefit from your perspective. (It’s a good idea to think about helping others with your words, rather than yourself). And you certainly don’t want to say things that require other people to do the work of comforting YOU and centering YOUR feelings about this. Keep it focused on those people who are actually impacted by the ugliness of racism, anti-semitism, anti-immigration, misogyny, and any of the other grab-bag of ugliness unleashed into the world.
But posting things on the internet does nothing! Bullshit. A culture war is brewing there and has been for some time now. Those assholes waving torches in Charlottesville were, less than ten years ago, dorks who met on a site called 4chan to talk about anime and how they were bad at talking to women. This is literally what happened. The online radicalization of young men is real, it is important, and it has to be combatted.
And those assholes in Charlottesville? They were seduced by people on the internet who appealed to their need to be blameless. Their need for things that are going wrong in their own lives to be someone else’s fault.
For every one of those assholes — and just to clear this point up, there are a lot more of them than just the ones you’ve now seen on TV — there are a bunch more well-intentioned white people who just need to be reminded of their need to be good. To be moral. To be on the right side of history.
Fight that fight on the internet, and lead by reminding others of the importance of being good. Call our your cousin with the cherry-picked meme about black-on-black crime statistics. Remind your aunt that, hey, our family came from Ellis Island, and it’s patriotic to extend that same courtesy to those in need. Check your sources before you post, so that you are only offering credible information. Tell your family members and extended circles and coworkers that you love them, but they are wrong to discriminate against others, to show bias against others, or to become hostile when someone points out that their whiteness might have led to some advantages in their life. Remind them that no one is asking them to feel guilty for being white. (That’s such a crock of myth, by the way. Not one person of color has ever asked me to apologize for being white. That’s just not a thing). Being aware that your life has advantages based on your skin color, and you believe that all people should be treated equally, is just not that radical of a position to take, although it’s being treated as such. So get out there and remind others that “all people are created equal” is patriotic as fuck, and it extends to immigrants and women and Jews and Muslims and the disabled and trans folks and every-body-god-damned-else.
Can I also still post pictures of my puppies and my kids? HELL YES. This is the whole point: that others in your world see you as fully human, and a full human being with a kickass recipe for crockpot pineapple barbecue chicken who ALSO thinks white supremacy is scary as shit and Nazis are bad. Be a fully dimensional person who is aware of, and actively convincing others, of those truths.
But I’m white! Shouldn’t I be amplifying black/Jewish/immigrant/marginalized voices? Yes! You should! You should make sure to post those too. But change starts within our own communities. And we’re not going to do shit about solving hatred if we don’t start by saying “I am a white person/Republican/American who is not okay with these people representing me. I recognize that this kind of hatred has always been here, and I will do better to listen to those who were trying to warn me of its existence. I disavow this, and will do my best to take action moving forward.”
But some people might get mad at me because they see that I’m posting on the internet but I’m not actually, I don’t know, attending meetings or organizing protests or getting arrested at my congressman’s office! If I’d been out on the front lines alone, I’d be mad too, wondering where the hell all of us white people have been. Let them be mad. It’s valid anger. But if that’s going to dissuade you from actually voicing your opinion on something important, and taking that first step towards confronting racism and prejudice, then you’re not strong enough to be on the front lines yet anyway. And most people understand that this takes time. If you’re voicing your opinion for the benefit of getting patted on the back by people of color, that’s pretty misguided. Voice your opinions because it’s the right thing to do. Especially when the opinion is “I think Nazis are bad.”
There are other next steps, and they’re really important too. Like: saying something about it in person. There are great blogs and resources that talk about how to do that effectively, and I’ll point you towards them.
Giving money is good. If you’ve got money to give, give it. (If you don’t, don’t waste time feeling guilty. Think about the other ways you can help in your own community instead). Look up local chapters of organizations that do good things. Here’s a good list of places. Here’s another, that includes action steps like calling your representatives and donating blood.
Going to a protest is good. Calling your representatives is good. Insisting on more diversity in your place of employment is good. Spending time reading up on actively anti-racist literature, or seeking to learn more about the history of institutionalized sexism/racism/discrimination is good. Reading this thing about how the internet emboldened hate is good. Becoming a source of knowledge for your community is good. Spending time with others in marginalized communities who need your help and support is good. Sending a care package to your friends who are struggling is good. Being on the front lines of a protest to shield people of color from police violence is good. All of those things are good.
But honestly…. a lot of you aren’t there yet. Hell, I’m not totally there yet. Okay. So I focused on the first one.
Say something about it.
Speak up. Speak up about what you believe in. Speak up when you see lengthy threads about local community issues. Speak up when that racist cartoon is shared. Speak up from behind your screen, when it happens, all the time. It’s so much easier than actually putting your body in physical danger. (And when you’re ready to do that, do that. People in marginalized communities have been shouldering that burden for waay too long). But for those of you who aren’t there yet…. find your voice first. And then use it for good.
But it isn’t enough! No. It’s not enough. It won’t be, for a very long time. It’s OK to say that out loud and know it to be true: “Whatever I am doing is not enough.” But it’s something. And you need to crawl before you can walk, which is a bummer, because recent current events require you to be in marathon condition. So get training.
In my country these devilish and evil swastika symbols on red flags are simply strictly forbidden. But why not in the USA?
“https://iambeggingmymothernottoreadthisblog.com/2017/08/13/a-brief-note-for-my-fellow-white-people-on-what-to-do-after-charlottesville/”
Something something freedom of speech.
PS: Make no mistake, I like Nazis being outlawed. But that is not the “American way” (alledgedly; I am not an American).
A rather suspect argument, freedom, because this Swastika symbol of the SS-regime in Germany is standing for a state-organized terrorism. The US American police would not tolerate on the other hand the Islamic State marching through the streets of Charlottesville with their black flags because of their fight against Islamist terrorism. So this actual anti-terrorist policy is not really honest or even consequent.
Give Americans a break. This was a WAKE-UP CALL. Maybe now even lily white supremacists will be viewed at terrorists and will not be allowed to march carrying Nazi or Confederate flags. You think?
Thank you for mentioning how they spread their rhetoric… I had to have the talk with my son today, because he didn’t realize how people actually go about joining the KKK. He thought people got angry and racist on their own and sought the group out; I had to tell him they host picnics and barbecues and never mention who or what they are until they’ve thoroughly tested the new guys and gotten some toxic ideas brewing in their heads.
Hate groups don’t advertise “Come hate with us!” They prey upon the vulnerable, put an arm around a dude’s shoulder and tell him there’s a better way.
True! I’m glad you wrote this. A lot of the people who hate and fear those who are different from themselves are the friendly family next door. Even then, they can be OK with me; it’s all those other Jews they hate. And they don’t see how crazy that is.
Katherine–your essay is brilliantly clear and beautiful. It should be posted on all social media and on all the networks. With your permission, I’ll post it on my FB page.
yup! everything on this page is always public and can be shared.
Pingback: A brief note for my fellow white people on what to do after Charlottesville | mbove
Thank you for your last blog post. I am a “mom reading your blog,” subscribes to your blog and I sent it to my kids. Keep it up.
I love the fact that my daughter is the one who posted it knowing I would read it. Love it!!!
You go girl. And, uh, oh, the rest of us go too right? #postedonallmysocmed just like the previous one was @amazingwomenrock.com and @SheQuotes.com and others.
Hate is wrong. Love even when you think it isn’t deserved for no matter who, is always right.
You are Brilliant. You just said everything I have been struggling to say. Now I can and will post this on my page and be glad to have it said.. Thank you.
Your courage and clarity are awesome. Thank you for sharing your thoughts and feelings. They are spot on.
Well written and helpful. Thanks!
Thank you. I appreciate the calm guidance. And Nazis are bad.
Thank you. On my own blog and social media accounts I asked my white friends and followers to go get y’all peoples together and talk amongst yourselves. POC folks are exhausted, and a lot of folks don’t listen to us anyway. This, this essay has done just that and provided homework. 👍🏾👍🏾👍🏾❤
Well said well said, from here in Australia. ‘Spread the word’- it’s so simple isn’t it? Nazis are fucken bad. And we already know this FFS, it’s called history…
Something to add to the list at the top of the blog: “that Bernie supporter shot at those Congressional Republicans while they practiced baseball”. Infuriating.
I am a teacher and want to use your blogs about Charlottesville. Would it be alright if I edited the language out of some of it to make it more classroom friendly? I love the way that you ask questions of the reader to make them think about themselves!
I am still waiting for you to say that not all trump voters are racist, neo-nazis. My grandmother’s parents immigrated from east Europe. They made it before Hitler rose to power. Hardly any of their siblings were as fortunate. My grandmother knew almost none of her aunts, uncles, cousins, or grandparents, because they worshiped in a way that was viewed as inferior. Even today, these sentiments remain. There are people -such as those in the rally- who hate her, and who hate me, because they think we have “inferior blood”. And yet, I am often said to be one of these people because I vote republican. Because I think things work better when we have free market capitalism, I am said to be the very person who despises me. Am I disappointed by my president’s response to this crisis? Do I believe he should to more to disassociate his name with this hate? Both yes, but I also think that calling trump voters at fault for this is just a poor attempt to try to define your enemy. Yes, true racists do tend to vote republican, but that in no way means all republicans are racist. They can’t control who supports them. Democrats have the support of communists, yet they are never said to all belong to that group. This weekend has showed us what true white supremacism is like, it’s not believing immigration laws should be enforced as this article claims.
Jason, she actually did say not all trump voters are racist. And she was egg-shell careful not to imply that being white or conservative or Republican makes anybody anything bad. Breathe in real slow. Hold it a second. Let it out real slow. Repeat until calm. You might want to re-read the piece.
Thank you – Spoken well – keep up the good fight.
I will, too.
…..Who else is going to step up?
Bravo! Saw your post on a friend’s FB page. We as POC can say it all day but we need our White allies take a stand too. Well done!!
Pingback: Surviving in the Trump Era with Sheet Cake and Cheap Rosé | OC Green Mama
Pingback: taking a stand – Rediscovery 101
Pingback: “I’m not like those other ‘bad’ white people.” | Riddle from the Middle
Thank you for posting this and for your other posts. This needs to be said, you say it so eloquently. Also, Nazis are bad.